By Mark Ames
I met Paul Klebnikov for an interview in late October, 1996. I had no idea why
he, a Forbes editor, would want to talk to me, editor of an annoying little
Moscow paper called "Living Here". We met at what is now the Murena Bar on
Gazetny Pereulok. Klebnikov didn't look like a typical frumpy journalist. His
clean narrow face, coiffed dark hair and healthy physique made him look like a
sort of corporate Adam Sandler. A very un-Jewish Adam Sandler, as I was to later
discover.
At the start of our interview, Klebnikov put a tape recorder on the
table and started the tape. He asked me about Living Here and : life among the
expats. Back then, I didn't go out or socialize much; I wanted to talk about
Russian politics. I noticed that my answers disappointed him. Then he asked me
about some local expat tradition whereby a large group of American expats would
charter a jet to Transvylania for a ribald Halloween at Dracula's castle. I told
him I had no idea what that was about. So I referred him to a couple of white-
baseball-capped expats who could tell him more. At that moment in our interview,
a strange thing happened: Klebnikov grabbed his tape recorder, clicked the
buttons, shook it, opened the tape, examined it, opened the battery case, took
out the batteries and put them back in, then clicked the buttons some more.
Finally he gave up.
"It doesn't seem to work," he told me. "Do you mind if I
just take notes and don't record it?"
After our interview, he asked me to take
him to a massive Halloween party near Smolensky Ploschad, thrown by the
legendary Otto and gang. On our way there, Klebnikov, who proudly told me that
he'd descended from White Russian emigres, passionately defended the regime of
Nikolai II. He'd written his PhD on the economics of the last Tsar's regime, and
claimed that it was neither as failed nor as doomed as its reputation had been,
and that it was actually on the right path all along. I found that strange
coming from a Berkeley grad and Forbes editor, but I still hadn't put two and
two together.
Vodka flowed freely. I lost Klebnikov somewhere near the coat
check, where he'd cornered another White Russian descendent and friend of mine,
whose name I will leave out since she still reads this newspaper.
After the
party, she and I went home together.
"Who was that asshole Paul Klebnikov?" she
kept asking, furious. "Is he a friend of yours?"
"No, he's an editor of Forbes
who came to interview me," I said. I thought he'd make me look good; I was
wrong.
"He's an unbelievable anti-Semite," she said. "All he would talk about is
how the Jews are destroying Russia. He thought that since I'm a White Russian
descendant, I'd agree. I didn't, but he wouldn't stop. He went on and on for
hours about the Jews. He's the worst anti-Semite I've ever met in my life!" When
his article in Forbes, "Moscow Cowboys", came out a couple of months later, I
finally understood why his tape machine conveniently conked out. Here's how he
quoted me then, and again in his Jew- baiting book on Berezovsky: "'Moscow is a
party town,' said Mark Ames, L 31, grinning, noticeably -Ithe worse for drink.
'Ninety-nine percent of the expats came here to make a buck, but they stayed for
the women'the women here are awesome [...] This party is nothing,' noted Ames.
'There's a group of 100 expats traveling down to Transylvania to spend Halloween
in Dracula's castle.'" I remember being shocked when I first read that. My first
big-time quotes ever, and I hadn't said a word of it. And the liar knew I
hadn't! It made me lose what little faith I had in the sanctity of journalistic
ethics - hell, even at Living Here we didn't intentionally misquote people, and we
had no standards to speak of.
I remember at one point in our interview,
Klebnikov asked me if I was Russian. I told him that I had a Ukrainian-Jewish
grandmother. That must be what sealed it for me. Judging by his Berezovsky
book's Third Reich cover, and his distinctly negative treatment of Jewish
oligarchs versus his positive treatment of Christian oli-garchs, I can see now
that it wasn't a mistake. I'd been marked for a smear.