Vanity Fair profiles The eXile: "Gutsy...visceral...serious journalism...abusive, defamatory...poignant...paranoid...and right!"
MSNBC: Mark Ames and Yasha Levine
Broke the Koch Brothers' Takeover of America
Troll Watch / January 24, 2012
By Max Blumenthal

This article is cross-posted from with permission from the author Max Blumenthal

For nearly a month, a group of foreign policy researcher-bloggers at the Center for American Progress (CAP), an influential liberal think tank based in Washington DC, have faced an unrelenting smear campaign. The smears, initiated by former AIPAC spokesman Josh Block, focused on a few sardonic tweets by CAP bloggers that raised the ire of the pro-Israel and neoconservative political community. One tweet that included the term “Israel Firster” received special attention.

“This kind of demagoguery, anti-Israel invective, and in some cases actual hate speech, is absolutely wrong whether it comes from the extreme Right or Left, and like cancer, it has to be cut out before it metastasizes and destroys the whole body,” Block complained to Jennifer Rubin, a neoconservative columnist for the Washington Post who has accused CAP of “anti-Semitism” and who was recently scolded by the paper’s ombudsman for endorsing a screed advocating the slaughter of Palestinians.

Block’s campaign was transparently designed to force the Democratic establishment to disown a group of researchers who had generated an effective and factually solid counter narrative to the case for a military strike on Iran. And it was well orchestrated, receiving robust and sustained amplification from the right-wing of the pro-Israel community. By January 19, after a who’s who of neoconservative writers and right-leaning Jewish American groups called for the firing of the researchers, and weeks after the small handful of “controversial” tweets had been deleted and apologized for, the smears graduated onto the pages of the Washington Post.

A report by Washington Post staff writer Peter Wallsten summarized the attacks on CAP in a relatively uncritical fashion. In the original edition of the story (uploaded here to Josh Block’s Scribd account), Wallsten featured remarks by Jeffrey Herf, whom he presented as an academic expert on anti-Semitism:

“Israel Firsters” is a point of disagreement.CAP officials and the think tank’s critics agree that the term is over the line. University of Maryland historian Jeffrey Herf, who has published books on anti-Semitism, said the phrase represented a “classic theme of modern anti-Semitism.” He said the suggestion of Jewish “dual loyalty,” along with the accusation that AIPAC was pushing for war with Iran, hearkened back to the early days of World War II, when certain people accused the U.S. government of entering the war as a response to powerful Jewish interests.

“This kind of nonsense is all over the place on the Internet,” Herf said. “The fact that some of this is showing up on the Center for American Progress Web site makes it important.”

In a lengthy blog post at the Atlanticformer Israeli prison guard Jeffrey Goldberg reproduced the Washington Post‘s Herf quote to buttress his attempts to prove that the term “Israel Firster” — an accusation he faces with increasing frequency — is anti-Semitic, and that the bloggers at CAP and a wide array of critics of Israel might therefore be driven by the irrational hatred of Jews.

Unfortunately for the Washington Post and Goldberg, Herf’s statement was utterly false: The term “Israel Firster” never appeared on CAP’s website as he claimed — it appeared in a small handful of Tweets out of a body of thousands published on the personal Twitter account of a blogger, Zaid Jilani, who recently quit the think tank. Further, Herf is not an academically recognized expert on anti-Semitism. He has published two books on Nazi propaganda; his University of Maryland bio states that Herf “specializ[es] in twentieth century Germany.”

In 2006, Herf joined a clique of hawkish neoliberal intellectuals to draft the Euston Manifesto, a full-throated endorsement of George W. Bush’s “war on terror” which claimed the Islamic Republic of Iran sought to carry out “a second Holocaust.” More recently, Herf joined Alan Dershowitz, Caroline Glick, John Bolton, Joe Lieberman and other ideologues as a talking head in the right-wing pro-Israel propaganda documentary,“Unmasked: Judeophobia and the Threat to Civilization.” In leveling false innuendo at CAP and its employees, Herf apparently allowed his ideological zealotry to get the best of him.

Soon after Herf’s quote appeared in Wallsten’s article, it quickly and mysterious disappeared from the article’s online version — and with no acknowledgement by Wallsten or the Post‘s editors. The quiet scrubbing of the quote seemed like a tacit admission by the Washington Post that the two aforementioned points were true: Herf’s statement was false, and Herf was not an academically credible or intellectually objective scholar of anti-Semitism. The task of explaining why the paper’s editors did not require Wallsten to publicly acknowledge the erroneous statement’s removal might ultimately fall to Washington Post ombudsman Patrick Pexton. Goldberg, for his part, still features the disappeared, discredited quote on his blog (and the link Goldberg provides to the Washington Post article does not even work).

Lifecycle of a Zombie Smear

Stage 1: Jeffrey Herf’s smear quote appears in Washington Post:

Stage 2: Discredited smear quote by Jeffrey Herf vanishes from WaPo article:

Stage 3: Ex-Camp Guard Jeffrey Goldberg reanimates discredited quote from the dead, even after quote disowned by Washington Post:

Curiously, Herf gave voice to attacks on CAP before he was quoted by the Washington Post. On December 28, Herf featured prominently in ahit piece published at the right-wing Jerusalem Post by neoconservative activist Benjamin Weinthal. Weinthal’s article included a segment that read almost like a mimeograph of the passage that had mysteriously disappeared from Wallsten’s article:

In a telephone conversation with the Jerusalem Post on Tuesday, University of Maryland historian Jeffrey Herf, who has authored books on anti-Semitism, said the phrase “Israel firsters” is “dangerous.” The notion of “Israel firsters” “delegitimizes support for Israel” and stokes the “dual-loyalty” charge against American Jews, he said.

The dual-loyalty conspiracy theory existed on “the far Left and far Right of American politics but has not yet seeped into the center of American politics,” Herf said.

Instead of performing a diligent search for a credible, academically renowned scholar of anti-Semitism, Wallsten apparently poached his source from Weinthal, a neocon zealot who has spent weeks crusading against CAP’s foreign policy research team. If Wallsten did not share Weinthal’s ulterior ideological motives, he was incredibly lazy.

Though Weinthal poses as a “correspondent” for the Jerusalem Post, he is in fact a research fellow for the Foundation for the Defense of Democracies (FDD), an ultra-hawkish think tank at the center of the push for American military intervention in Iran.

Underlining the incestuous right-wing nature of the smear campaign against CAP, another FDD fellow, James Kirchick, took to the Israeli daily Haaretz to accuse Jilani and other left-wing writers of parroting the rhetoric of the long-deceased anti-Semitic conspiracist Willis Carto by using the term “Israel firster” (I’m sure Jilani was cutting and pasting Carto’s old newsletters directly into his Twitter postings). Meanwhile, Kirchick oversaw an off-the-record email listserv called the Freedom Community that provided a private forum for neoconservative activists and writers to devise strategy and talking points. Josh Block, a Freedom Community member, initiated the smear campaign against CAP by shopping his trove of “research” to fellow email list members, who then disseminated the information in the form of op-eds and blog posts.

FDD’s leadership bears a longstanding grudge against the CAP bloggers it is now targeting. CAP researcher Eli Clifton, who produced a damaging report on FDD’s funding sources and who reported that the Islamophobic mass killer Anders Breivik cited FDD in his manifesto, is a particular nuisance to the think tank. FDD also has an axe to grind with Ali Gharib, who revealed in December 2010 (before CAP hired him) that FDD held a fundraiser at the Pakistani ambassador to the US’s house without bothering to tell the embassy it was hosting a hawkish conference on Iran where money was raised for FDD. Given the damaging stories Clifton and Gharib produced about FDD, is there any wonder the think tank provided encouragement and promotion for Weinthal and Kirchick’s attacks?

While Weinthal and Kirchick launched their attacks from the shores of the neocon right, Jeffrey Goldberg waded into the campaign against CAP under the cover of mainstream Beltway respectability. In his bid to legitimize the smears, however, Goldberg (who has deceptively accused me of “quote fabrication”) wound up hanging his argument on an erroneous quote that has since been scrubbed by its original source. Unless he is comfortable hosting a false and now non-existent quote on his blog, Goldberg might consider issuing a correction.

This article is cross-posted from with permission from the author Max Blumenthal. Would you like to know more? Read “How Israeli Occupation Forces, Bahraini Monarchy Guards Trained U.S. Police For Coordinated Crackdown on “Occupy” Protests” by Max Blumenthal, and “Max Blumenthal Responds To Sleaze Campaign Waged By Atlantic Monthly’s Ex-Detention Camp Guard Jeffrey Goldberg…And Why The Atlantic Monthly’s Sleaze Reminds Us Of Putin’s Russia” by Max Blumenthal and Mark Ames.

You can read more of Max Blumenthal at He is the author of Republican Gomorrah, published by Nation Books.



We’re launching a media transparency project to unmask corrupt shills and corporate trolls…

A recent spate of corrupt hack-shill attacks on Team eXiled has prompted us to decide to make an immediate launch of a new project: a no-holds barred campaign to identify and expose corrupt shills and corporate trolls among political journalists and bloggers in the US.

The outpouring from readers in light of our recent exposes of people like Glenn GreenwaldEzra KleinJoshua FoustAdam SerwerMegan McArdleDavid WeigelJane HamsherMalcolm Gladwell and many others has been fantastic — we know you’ve got our back. We’ll need it.

Can you help us out? Contribute using PayPal or WePay.

Our computers are bulging with files on corrupt publications, bloggers and journalists, and it’s time to get it all out in the open. We’re going to launch a separate website, and a slick corporate troll tracking platform to do it.

We will go after the usual pro-corporate/business bloggers posing under the fake ideology of libertarianism and the utterly corrupted religious and right-wing media. But most importantly, we are going to expose the wolves in the progressive henhouse. The blogosphere has a very short memory, allowing blog pundits to hide from their past shilling campaigns. But not anymore…

Your money will help pay for FOIA requests, inevitable lawyer fees, travel costs to visit archives, and much more. This is serious work. We need your help.

Contribute using PayPal or WePay.


Add your own

  • 1. darthfader  |  January 24th, 2012 at 4:48 pm

    I guess it’s not surprising that a tubby hubby like Goldberg pushed dudes around with his baton at an IDF prison camp.

  • 2. G Marks  |  January 25th, 2012 at 4:57 am

    Jews hate Gentiles – as much as Jews hate Jews, probably less so. But I’m a racist bottom troll. sieg heil’ing my pure pasty white Internet brethren, doing secret handshakes and shit…

    To portray Jews as saintly in their multi cultural goodness is bunk. Coca-cola jingles are for jingles. Censorship if for monkeys. I am a monkey.

    and yes, I admit to anti semitism. It’s the proper response from a racist bottom troll, who got his wife snatched by a Latino and who is now focused on an ethnocentric cabal that infests and destroys host cultures, while claiming sainthood. Always wondering, why is Max Blumenthal outing other Jews and why is a site infested by Jews running a Jew that is criticizing fellow Jews? Must be one of their advanced Zionist conspiracies that I’m too fucking dumb to understand.

    The fact that my wife left me for a Latino guy makes me a Jew hater. So be it.

    they certainly hate me – and steal me blind if I let them. That Latino guy sure did.

  • 3. charles sereno  |  January 25th, 2012 at 6:11 am

    Just curious. Has the term “Israelophile” gotten any traction?

  • 4. Bobby  |  January 25th, 2012 at 9:42 am

    Jews have it good just about anywhere they go, They need to shut the fuck up and stop bitching.

    Jew woprship is a fullblown religion in America.

    Yahweh responds:

    As soon as illiterate retards learn how to spell “woprship” properly, Jews might stop bitching.

  • 5. Bobby  |  January 25th, 2012 at 10:47 am


    Thank you for pointing out the error of my dumbshit ways, oh Almighty Exiled Censor!

  • 6. Cum  |  January 25th, 2012 at 11:08 am

    “like cancer, it has to be cut out before it metastasizes and destroys the whole body”

    That’s funny, I’ve read interviews and quotes where the same exact sentiment was offered up by German Nazis, Argentinian ‘Dirty War’ torturers, and other fascistic murderers, as an explanation for the need to exterminate leftist/Jewish/minority segments of society. Any time you hear this sort of terminology used to describe people, it should set off an alarm in your head. It’s a sign that you may be dealing with an aspiring jackbooted thug.

    This kind of demagoguery, anti-humanitarian invective, and in some cases actual hate speech, is absolutely wrong whether it comes from Nazis or Zionists, and like cancer, it has to be cut out before it metastasizes and destroys the whole body! 😉

  • 7. Down and Out of Sài Gòn  |  January 25th, 2012 at 2:50 pm

    There’s nothing wrong with being an “Israel Firster”, but there’s a conflict of interest if you hold American office at the same time.

  • 8. Fake name  |  January 25th, 2012 at 7:52 pm

    @7 I think we should always put people first. If I am building a settlement in the middle of your agricultural land, the first thought in my head should not be “well you are not Israeli, so it’s ok”.

    Of course the Palestininians should also consider their actions in the same light. However, there is a slight power imbalance here, and the actions of the average Palestinian has far less impact on Israelis than the action of an average Israeli on a Palestinian.

  • 9. Fake name  |  January 25th, 2012 at 7:57 pm

    @7 which of course does not invalidate your point about the confoict of interest with being an Israel Firster and holding American political office…

  • 10. Pecan  |  January 26th, 2012 at 12:31 am

    I don’t really know how to read. Sorry, my problem is that I’m kind of slow in the head ever since I was born, there is too much water in my head.

    Please get me some brain matter, Mark. Even your pretty terms of readability.

  • 11. Strelnikov  |  January 26th, 2012 at 3:30 am

    According to Sam Smith over at the Progressive Review the Israelis have given Obama 12 hour warning whenever they finally get around to attacking Iran. Which will be pointless in stopping them from developing a nuke because they’re five years from that anyway.

    I just want the Israelis to try, just so we can see panicked IDF/AF pilots on Iranian TV.

  • 12. super390  |  January 26th, 2012 at 3:35 pm

    Being a Zionist is necessarily putting a high priority on the State of Israel regardless of your own country’s interests. Whether it’s “Israel first” depends on the objective harm done to your country, and boy could we have discussions about that. There are a lot of Christians in America who are now Israel-firsters; they’ve given up on their own country’s future and are looking at Israel to provide their ticket to the Rapture. John Hagee is building facilities in illegal Israeli settlements and working with groups trying to demand Israeli citizenship for American Christian fundamentalists so they can emigrate, flood the country, take over and start Armageddon themselves. How’s that for Israel first, Goldberg?

  • 13. Zhu Bajie  |  January 31st, 2012 at 2:55 am

    “John Hagee is building facilities in illegal Israeli settlements and working with groups trying to demand Israeli citizenship for American Christian fundamentalists so they can emigrate, flood the country, take over and start Armageddon themselves.”

    Maybe Hagee et al. can pick the tomatoes, do the construction work, etc.?

  • 14. seo  |  January 31st, 2012 at 9:28 am

    Hey there! Quick question that’s totally off topic. Do you know how to make your site mobile friendly? My site looks weird when browsing from my iphone 4. I’m trying to find a theme or plugin that might be able to fix this problem. If you have any suggestions, please share. Many thanks!

Leave a Comment

(Open to all. Comments can and will be censored at whim and without warning.)


Required, hidden

Subscribe to the comments via RSS Feed